BrandonH - Not once in this entire shift did you either participate in your role nor supervise as you claimed you were doing

Username: BrandonH

Banned Roles: Chemist

Ban reason: Not once in this entire shift did you either participate in your role nor supervise as you claimed you were doing.
Length of ban: Indefinite
Ban Issue:
What I was banned for is not against the rules

Vote Opt-Out: false

Events leading to the ban

You will have to zoom into the image.

5:28-5:58 ( stood in place before opening PDA, checking to see if we have a cmo ) [ Wasn't AFK was just standing still waiting ] 
5:58-6:16 ( standing still still until saying, oh what the fuck ) [ Was checking the map files and saw that it only had one round start chemist ] - 18 seconds tabed out 
6:22-7:34 ( standing still, before asking CMO for another chemist ) [ Started working on PR ] - 90 seconds tabed out 
Other chemists arrives. I greet them and say "This place is all yours"
8:02-10:55 ( standing still ) [ working on PR 1 ] 263 seconds tabed out 
13:50-14:20 ( standing still ) [ Still working on PR 1] 293 seconds tabed out
Other chemist asking "Please can you change your job or do work?" ( hostility )
Other chemists asks me to go roam the station
Other chemist tells me they will go to hop if i'm not working ( Hostility )
I didn't respond to them threatening to get me fired because there is no point and would just lead to a bad situation.
Power goes out in chemistry
15:40 - 16:12 [ Working on PR 1 ]326 seconds tabed out 
[ Side note, at somepoints that I was tabbed out I would tab back in to see If there was anything I needed to do or if anyone wanted anything from me ]
[ Knowing this is very difficult because of how the chat works, extremely hard to notice if someone is talking to you with the chat flowing so quickly and no notification when someone says your name ]

Crane asks me to go find plasma.
I tell them I can't leave my post.
I then ask the scientist if they can bring us plasma.
the scientist agrees to bring us plasma.

[ Side note. There was a wrench on the ground that I did not notice. If I was paying closer attention I could had immeditely gotten plasma for crane without having to leave the chemistry lab ]
[ Haven't played chemistry in a WHILE so me missing that is kinda to be expected. ]

17:25-19:13 ( standing still, tabbed out ) 434
Checks crew manifest to see if we have a CMO yet.
We do
19:24-19:53 463
20:12-20:44 485
20:45-21:50 550

23:50 ( I ask if the chemist made any advanced brute, they reply "I'm reporting you mate" ) 
[ I was thinking about teaching them how to make advanced brute the quick way ]


[ They left chemistry ]
25---- ( ask crane to come to the chemistry lab so I can assist them with making more chemicals after noticing medbay is lacking )
[ They say "CMO I will quit chemistry if anteros is not removed" ] ( more hostility, while i'm trying to help )
[ I'm completely ignored by the other chemist while trying to help medbay produce more medicine ]

26:50 notice that the chemical dispeners have no hitbox
( tries talking to the other chemist and is completely ignored )
27:36 ( other chemist walks out of chemistry immeditely after I tried talking to them )

[i start working on PR 2 since the other chemist obviously does not want to work with me and there's nothing i can do about it ]
27:38-27:48 560

27:55-28:18 583

28:30 ( I ask the other chemist for paper, which they completely ignore )

[ I asked them for paper because I planned on keeping track of everything that was made in medbay and everything that needed to be made ]
[ Planning on supervisoring by keeping track of the inventory of chemicals ]
( compltely ignored by the other chemist )

28:50-31:13 [ Working on PR 2 ] 726

I never alt tabbed or went afk after this point

31:48 ( Ask the other chem what chems they have made so far So i can better keep track of what is made and what we need. ) [ Hard to track because they are using machines ]
[ They ignore me again ]
[ They leave chemistry ]

32:45 ( I comment on the lack of communication in chemistry)

Killed at 46:40

========================================================

13:50-14:20 ( standing still ) [ Still working on PR 1] 293 seconds tabed out
Other chemist asking "Please can you change your job or do work?" ( hostility )
Other chemists asks me to go roam the station
Other chemist tells me they will go to hop if i'm not working ( Hostility )
I didn't respond to them threatening to get me fired because there is no point and would just lead to a bad situation.
23:50 ( I ask if the chemist made any advanced brute, they reply "I'm reporting you mate" ) 
[ I was thinking about teaching them how to make advanced brute the quick way ]
[ They left chemistry ]
25---- ( ask crane to come to the chemistry lab so I can assist them with making more chemicals after noticing medbay is lacking )
[ They say "CMO I will quit chemistry if anteros is not removed" ] ( more hostility, while i'm trying to help )
[ I'm completely ignored by the other chemist while trying to help medbay produce more medicine ]
26:50 notice that the chemical dispeners have no hitbox
( tries talking to the other chemist and is completely ignored )
27:36 ( other chemist walks out of chemistry immeditely after I tried talking to them )

[i start working on PR 2 since the other chemist obviously does not want to work with me and there's nothing i can do about it ]
28:30 ( I ask the other chemist for paper, which they completely ignore )

[ I asked them for paper because I planned on keeping track of everything that was made in medbay and everything that needed to be made ]
[ Planning on supervisoring by keeping track of the inventory of chemicals ]
( compltely ignored by the other chemist )
31:48 ( Ask the other chem what chems they have made so far So i can better keep track of what is made and what we need. ) [ Hard to track because they are using machines ]
[ They ignore me again ]
[ They leave chemistry ]

32:45 ( I comment on the lack of communication in chemistry)

Reason the ban should be removed

Every reason stated in the attached screen shot.

Also, Am I actually getting banned for not making chems when I have been bowinked and had notes added for apparently making “too many” chems?

An admin literally told me to do something different.
I did, and I get banned for it?!?

Supervisor part makes no sense, look at attached image.

Alternate Accounts

image

Ban note is also extremely dramatic.

“45 minutes of near total inactivity”

I was tabbed out/afk for 12 minutes and 6 seconds.
~26% of the round

Some of that time I was still in the game and was looking at chemistry and chat to see if there was anything to be done. [ Can’t figure out how much since I didn’t move while doing so ]

A decent portion of the time tabbed out/afk was due to the other chemist hostility.

I was tabbed in and doing stuff for the the other ~74% of the game.



This person has two large beakers, one in their backpack and one in their machine.

Admitting to taking the beakers

After Reviewing this Alongside a Head Administrator.

We have both agreed that your actions from this round do constitute abandonment of a role.

Actively refusing to partake in your duties because you are “Supervising” Is not the duty of a chemist, and is something we would also take issue with from commanding staff whom are expected to take on even further work loads.

This appeal is Denied. The ban will remain in place for it’s full duration.

To enable speedy review of all appeals, appeals that meet certain requirements may bypass the standard, often lengthy, review process. Our banning policy requires appeals which are denied using the speedy review process have this notice placed on them. Any of the following criteria typically make an appeal eligible for the speedy review process:

  • the ban is temporary and the player indicated on the appeal that they are ok with it being processed without a vote,
  • the ban length is less than or equal to 14 days,
  • the appeal is older than 7 days, or
  • the result of the appeal is obvious.

You may make a staff complaint if you believe this appeal was handled improperly, but should be aware that this will typically only result in a review of the processing of the appeal itself, with the appeal being re-opened if an issue is found. An appeal is considered to have been processed improperly if the criteria to use the speedy review process was not met, or if the facts which the processing admin relied on to process the appeal were incorrect. You must concisely describe why you believe the appeal was handled improperly. If no issue is found with the processing of the appeal, the appeal itself will not be re-reviewed. If, in bad faith, you claim that an appeal was handled improperly, the reviewing head admin may decide to extend the time you must wait before you appeal and/or extend your ban duration.

Added appeal-rejected and removed appeal-pending

This topic was automatically closed 3 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.